• Home
  • The Company
  • Services
  • How It Works
  • Pricing
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Suite 3AB, 4th Floor, No 34/36 Ikorodu Road, Jibowu, Lagos
  • +2349132683414
  • [email protected]
  • Home
  • The Company

      Our Agency

      Writely is a leading content writing agency in Nigeria, delivering tailored solutions for businesses and individuals.

      Learn More

      Our Values

      To provide professional content and writing services in Nigeria, creating impactful content that resonates with audiences and drives success.

      Learn More

      Our Vision and Mission

      We aim to be the go-to content writing agency in Nigeria, empowering every story to inspire and connect.

      Learn More

      FAQs

      Find answers to questions about our content writing services and processes in Nigeria.

      Learn More

  • Services
  • How It Works
  • Pricing
  • Blog
  • Contact
Free Consultant

  • Home
  • The Company

      Our Agency

      Writely is a leading content writing agency in Nigeria, delivering tailored solutions for businesses and individuals.

      Learn More

      Our Values

      To provide professional content and writing services in Nigeria, creating impactful content that resonates with audiences and drives success.

      Learn More

      Our Vision and Mission

      We aim to be the go-to content writing agency in Nigeria, empowering every story to inspire and connect.

      Learn More

      FAQs

      Find answers to questions about our content writing services and processes in Nigeria.

      Learn More

  • Services
  • How It Works
  • Pricing
  • Blog
  • Contact
Free Consultant

Content Writing

Systematic Review vs Literature Review: Key Differences

By Splendor 

“Can I do a systematic review for my project?” It is one of the questions supervisors hear most often, and also one of the most misunderstood. Many students use the word “systematic” simply because they searched a few databases. Others write a normal literature review and call it a systematic review, hoping it sounds more impressive. Panels notice, and the mismatch can cost marks or force a rewrite.

The two types of review serve different purposes, follow different rules and demand very different amounts of time and rigour. A literature review helps you understand a topic and justify your own study. A systematic review is itself a research study, with a protocol, a documented search and a transparent method that others should be able to repeat.

This guide explains the difference clearly, shows you when to use each, walks through the steps of a systematic review and helps you decide which fits your project. If you would like an expert to review your plan or write-up, see our research proposal writing and dissertation writing services.

Table of Contents

Toggle
  • What Is a Literature Review?
  • What Is a Systematic Review?
  • Systematic Review vs Literature Review: Key Differences
  • Other Review Types You Will Meet
  • Which One Should You Choose for Your Project?
    • Quick Decision Guide
  • How to Do a Systematic Review: Step by Step
    • Step 1: Define a Focused Question
    • Step 2: Write a Protocol
    • Step 3: Set Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria
    • Step 4: Search Several Databases
    • Step 5: Build a Search String
    • Step 6: Manage and Screen Records
    • Step 7: Create a PRISMA Flow Diagram
    • Step 8: Extract Data
    • Step 9: Assess Quality or Risk of Bias
    • Step 10: Synthesise the Findings
    • Step 11: Write and Report
  • How to Write a Strong Literature Review (the More Common Task)
  • Using a “Systematic Approach” in a Literature Review
  • Common Mistakes (and How to Avoid Them)
  • Ethics in Reviews
  • Using Academic Support Responsibly
  • Review Type Checklist
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Need Help Choosing and Writing the Right Review?

What Is a Literature Review?

A literature review is a critical discussion of existing research on a topic. In a thesis or dissertation, it usually forms Chapter 2 (or part of the proposal), and it serves several purposes:

  • Defines key concepts and theories.
  • Shows what is already known.
  • Compares and critiques earlier studies.
  • Identifies a gap that your study will address.
  • Justifies your research questions and method.

Traditional (narrative) literature reviews are organised by theme or argument, not as a list of studies. The author selects sources using judgement. A good one is still careful and honest about how sources were found, but there is no formal, repeatable protocol. For a full walkthrough, read our guide on how to write a literature review.

What Is a Systematic Review?

A systematic review is a research method that uses an explicit, pre-planned and reproducible process to find, select, appraise and synthesise all relevant studies on a clearly defined question. Its aim is to give the most complete and least biased summary of the evidence, so conclusions do not depend on which articles the author happened to find.

Key features:

  • A focused research question, often structured with a framework such as PICO (Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome).
  • A written protocol made before the review begins.
  • Clear inclusion and exclusion criteria.
  • A comprehensive, documented search across several databases.
  • Screening of studies, usually by two reviewers independently.
  • Data extraction with a standard form.
  • Quality or risk-of-bias assessment of each included study.
  • Synthesis of results, narrative or statistical.
  • Transparent reporting, commonly following the PRISMA guidelines.

Systematic reviews are common in health sciences, education, psychology and social policy, where decisions depend on combining evidence from many studies.

Systematic Review vs Literature Review: Key Differences

FeatureLiterature review (narrative)Systematic review
Main purposeBackground, context and identifying a gap for your own studyAnswer a specific question by summarising all relevant evidence
Is it a research study in itself?Usually no, it supports your studyYes, it is the study
Research questionBroad topic or objectivesNarrow, specific, structured question
ProtocolNot requiredRequired, planned in advance and often registered
SearchSelective, flexible, not always documentedComprehensive, multi-database, documented and reproducible
Selection criteriaInformal or impliedExplicit inclusion and exclusion criteria
Number of reviewersOne authorUsually two or more, independently
Quality appraisalInformal critiqueFormal tools to assess risk of bias or quality
SynthesisThematic discussion and critiqueStructured narrative synthesis, sometimes meta-analysis
ReportingFlexible structureStandardised, often PRISMA, with a flow diagram
Risk of biasHigher, as selection depends on the authorLower, because methods reduce selection bias
Time and effortWeeks to monthsOften many months, and usually a team
Typical lengthChapter or sectionFull article or complete dissertation

The simplest way to remember it: a literature review tells you what has been written. A systematic review answers a question using a transparent method for finding and judging that writing.

Other Review Types You Will Meet

TypeWhat it isQuick note
Scoping reviewMaps the extent and nature of research on a broad topic, without judging quality in depthUseful when the field is new or wide; follows methods such as those from the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) and PRISMA-ScR
Rapid reviewA faster, simplified systematic reviewShortcuts must be stated honestly
Integrative reviewCombines different types of evidence (quantitative, qualitative, theory)Common in nursing and education
Critical reviewEvaluates and challenges the literatureMore analysis than description
Umbrella reviewReviews systematic reviewsNeeds many existing reviews on the topic
Meta-analysisA statistical method that combines numerical results from several studiesA technique, not a type of review by itself. Many systematic reviews do not include one
Mixed methods reviewCombines quantitative and qualitative evidenceAdvanced, so discuss with your supervisor

A frequent confusion: a meta-analysis is not the same as a systematic review. A systematic review may or may not include a meta-analysis, depending on whether the studies are similar enough to combine statistically.

Which One Should You Choose for Your Project?

Ask these questions in order.

  1. What does your department require? Many undergraduate and master’s projects require primary data collection with a literature review chapter. Some departments allow a review-only project, and some specify which type. Ask your supervisor first.
  2. What is the purpose? If the review is to set up and justify your own study, a literature review is the right choice. If the review is the study itself, consider a systematic or scoping review.
  3. Is your question narrow and answerable from existing studies? Systematic reviews need a focused question and enough published studies.
  4. Do you have the time and skills? A genuine systematic review is demanding. Searching several databases, screening hundreds of records, extracting data and assessing quality is a lot of work for one student.
  5. Do you have access? You need access to databases and full-text articles, which depend on your library.
  6. Can you get a second reviewer? Independent screening is standard practice, and if you cannot arrange it, you must state this limitation.
  7. Is your field suitable? Systematic reviews work best when there are comparable studies. In areas with few or very different studies, a scoping or narrative review may be more realistic.

Quick Decision Guide

SituationBest fit
Chapter 2 of a thesis or dissertationLiterature review
Proposal that must show a gapLiterature review
Review-only project, narrow question, many comparable studiesSystematic review (if permitted)
Broad or emerging field, want to map what existsScoping review
Short timeline, solo student, department allows review projectsCarefully scoped narrative or rapid review, honestly described
You want to combine numerical results statisticallySystematic review with meta-analysis (advanced, needs statistical support)

Whatever you choose, name it honestly. Calling a narrative review “systematic” is misleading. For help weighing the options alongside primary research, read quantitative vs qualitative research and how to write a research proposal.

How to Do a Systematic Review: Step by Step

The steps below follow the logic used in widely accepted guidance, such as the PRISMA statement and the Cochrane Handbook. Always follow your department’s requirements.

Step 1: Define a Focused Question

Use a structure to make your question precise. Common frameworks:

FrameworkStands forBest for
PICOPopulation, Intervention, Comparison, OutcomeClinical and intervention questions
PEOPopulation, Exposure, OutcomeQuestions about factors or experiences
SPIDERSample, Phenomenon of Interest, Design, Evaluation, Research typeQualitative and mixed evidence

Example (illustrative, PEO):

  • Population: small traders in Nigeria
  • Exposure: use of mobile payment platforms
  • Outcome: factors influencing adoption or non-adoption

Question: What factors influence the adoption of mobile payment platforms among small traders in Nigeria?

Our guide to how to write research questions and hypotheses covers how to make questions focused and answerable.

Step 2: Write a Protocol

A protocol is a short plan, written before you begin, that states your question, eligibility criteria, databases, search strategy, screening process, data to extract, quality tools and synthesis method. It prevents you from changing the rules after seeing the results. In health fields, protocols are often registered on PROSPERO. Students outside health can still write a protocol and submit it to their supervisor, or register it on a platform such as the Open Science Framework if allowed.

Step 3: Set Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria

Decide in advance which studies count. Typical criteria include population, topic, study design, years, language and publication type.

CriterionIncludeExclude
PopulationSmall traders or micro-enterprise ownersLarge corporations, consumers only
TopicAdoption or use of mobile paymentsUnrelated technologies
LocationNigeria (or sub-Saharan Africa, if justified)Other regions
DesignEmpirical studies (quantitative or qualitative)Opinion pieces without data
Years2015 to the present (justify the date)Earlier studies
LanguageEnglishOther languages (note as a limitation)
PublicationPeer-reviewed articles, plus identified grey literature if plannedUnpublished with no accessible methods

These replace the sampling decisions you would make in a primary study. For comparison, see sampling techniques in research.

Step 4: Search Several Databases

Searching only Google or one database is not enough. Choose databases suited to your field, such as:

  • Health and life sciences: PubMed/MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL
  • Multidisciplinary: Scopus, Web of Science
  • Education: ERIC
  • Business and social science: EBSCO databases, JSTOR
  • African research: African Journals Online (AJOL), which is particularly useful for Nigerian and African studies
  • Supplementary: Google Scholar, reference lists of included studies and relevant organisation reports (grey literature)

Ask your university librarian which databases you can access. Record the database name, date of search, exact search string and number of results for each one.

Step 5: Build a Search String

Combine keywords with Boolean operators:

  • AND narrows (both terms must appear).
  • OR broadens (either term).
  • Quotation marks keep phrases together.
  • Asterisk (*) finds word endings (for example, trader* finds trader and traders).

Example (illustrative):

("mobile payment*" OR "mobile money" OR "digital payment*")
AND ("small trader*" OR "micro-enterprise*" OR "informal trader*" OR "small business*")
AND (Nigeria OR "sub-Saharan Africa")

Syntax differs between databases, so adjust for each one and test the string.

Step 6: Manage and Screen Records

  1. Export results into a reference manager such as Zotero.
  2. Remove duplicates.
  3. Screen titles and abstracts against your criteria. Free tools such as Rayyan are popular for this stage, though features and plans change.
  4. Retrieve full texts of the remaining studies and screen them again.
  5. Record the reasons for excluding each full-text study.

Ideally, two reviewers screen independently and resolve disagreements by discussion. If you are working alone, state this as a limitation and consider asking your supervisor or a colleague to check a sample.

Step 7: Create a PRISMA Flow Diagram

The PRISMA flow diagram shows how many records were found, screened, excluded and included. You can download templates from the PRISMA statement website. An illustrative flow (invented numbers):

StageRecords
Records identified from databases842
Duplicates removed210
Records screened (title and abstract)632
Records excluded at screening540
Full-text articles assessed92
Full-text articles excluded (with reasons)70
Studies included in the review22

Step 8: Extract Data

Create a standard extraction form (a table in Word or Excel) and collect the same details from every study, such as:

  • Author, year and country
  • Aim and design
  • Sample and setting
  • Measures or key concepts
  • Main findings
  • Limitations noted

This is similar to building a research instrument, so keep it consistent. Our guide to how to design a questionnaire shows how clear structure reduces errors, and the same logic applies to extraction forms.

Step 9: Assess Quality or Risk of Bias

Use an appropriate checklist for the study designs you included. Common examples include:

  • CASP checklists (casp-uk.net) for many designs
  • JBI critical appraisal tools (jbi.global)
  • Cochrane risk-of-bias tools for randomised trials
  • Newcastle-Ottawa Scale for some observational studies

Report how quality affected your conclusions. Studies of low quality should not carry the same weight as strong ones.

Step 10: Synthesise the Findings

  • Narrative synthesis: summarising and comparing findings by theme, with tables. This is the most common approach when studies are too different to combine statistically.
  • Meta-analysis: statistically combining results when studies are similar enough. It requires careful statistical knowledge and usually specialised software, such as RevMan or R packages, and is often beyond a typical undergraduate project. General statistics packages are covered in our beginner’s guide to SPSS, but meta-analysis needs extra methods, so seek expert guidance.
  • Thematic synthesis (qualitative): coding findings from qualitative studies into themes. See NVivo for qualitative analysis for coding ideas.
  • Mixed methods synthesis: combining both kinds of evidence, which links to mixed methods research.

Step 11: Write and Report

Follow PRISMA’s reporting checklist (available on the PRISMA website). A typical structure includes: abstract, introduction, methods (protocol, criteria, search, screening, extraction, appraisal, synthesis), results (flow diagram, study characteristics, quality, findings), discussion (interpretation, limitations, implications) and conclusion.

Be honest about limitations, such as language restrictions, single-reviewer screening, missing studies or low-quality evidence.

How to Write a Strong Literature Review (the More Common Task)

Most students need a literature review rather than a systematic review. To make yours strong:

  1. Define your scope from your objectives and research questions.
  2. Search widely and keep a record of what you searched and when, even though it is not a formal protocol.
  3. Read critically, not just descriptively. Compare methods, findings and weaknesses.
  4. Organise by theme or argument, not by author.
  5. Synthesise. Show how studies relate, agree and disagree.
  6. End with a clear gap that leads into your study.
  7. Paraphrase properly and cite everything. See our guide on how to avoid plagiarism in your dissertation and our APA 7th edition referencing guide.

Your literature review should support the problem you have set out. See how to write a problem statement for how the gap connects to the problem.

Using a “Systematic Approach” in a Literature Review

You can borrow good habits from systematic reviews without claiming to have done one. For example, you can keep a search log, state your databases and keywords, define clear inclusion criteria and explain how you selected sources, and then describe the work honestly as “a structured literature review” or “a narrative review with a documented search”. This adds transparency and makes your review easier to defend.

Common Mistakes (and How to Avoid Them)

MistakeWhy it is a problemWhat to do instead
Calling a narrative review “systematic”Misdescribes your methodUse the correct label, or follow a full systematic method
No protocolCannot show you did not change the rulesWrite and keep a protocol before searching
Searching one database or Google onlyMisses relevant studiesUse several suitable databases and record searches
Not recording search strings and datesNot reproducibleKeep a search log
Vague or too broad questionHundreds of unrelated studiesNarrow with PICO or PEO
No inclusion criteriaSelection looks arbitraryDefine criteria in advance
Cherry-picking studies that support your viewBiased conclusionsInclude all studies that meet criteria
Ignoring study qualityWeak studies distort conclusionsAppraise quality and discuss it
Confusing meta-analysis with systematic reviewTechnical errorRemember meta-analysis is only one possible synthesis method
One reviewer, not acknowledgedHidden bias riskState it as a limitation or arrange a second checker
Summarising studies one by one in a literature reviewDescriptive, not criticalOrganise by theme and compare
Copying text from sourcesPlagiarismParaphrase, cite and use quotations sparingly

Ethics in Reviews

Reviews of published studies normally do not involve recruiting participants, so they may not need the same ethical approval as primary research, but rules differ by institution. Ask your department whether approval or a declaration is needed. Integrity still matters: report all relevant studies honestly, do not misrepresent findings, cite properly and disclose any conflicts of interest. If you combine a review with primary data collection, read how to write a research ethics statement.

Using Academic Support Responsibly

Feedback, model examples, search guidance and editing can help you plan and present a review. Whatever help you use, your final work must follow your university’s rules on authorship and academic integrity, reflect your own decisions and be something you can explain and defend. Examiners often ask why you chose your review type and how you selected your studies, so practise with our list of 40 dissertation defence questions. For help getting useful comments from your supervisor, see how to work with your dissertation supervisor.

Review Type Checklist

  • Have I confirmed with my supervisor which type of review my department allows?
  • Is my purpose clear (background for my study, or the review as the study)?
  • If I call it systematic, do I have a protocol, explicit criteria, a documented multi-database search and a transparent screening process?
  • Have I used a structured question framework such as PICO or PEO?
  • Have I recorded search strings, dates and results?
  • Have I created a flow diagram showing how studies were selected?
  • Have I assessed the quality of included studies?
  • Have I stated limitations honestly, including single-reviewer screening or language limits?
  • If it is a literature review, is it organised by theme and does it end with a clear gap?
  • Have I paraphrased and cited every source?

For further guidance on academic writing and citation, see Purdue OWL. For programme standards, see the National Universities Commission, and check your department’s handbook, since expectations differ. Methodological guidance is also available from the Cochrane Handbook and JBI.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between a systematic review and a literature review? A literature review gives a critical overview of a topic, usually to set up and justify your own research. A systematic review is a research method with a pre-planned protocol, a comprehensive documented search and transparent selection, appraisal and synthesis, designed to answer a specific question.

Is a systematic review better than a literature review? Neither is better in general. They have different purposes. A systematic review gives stronger, less biased evidence on a narrow question, but it takes much more work. A literature review is the right tool for background and context in most projects.

Can I do a systematic review as a final year project? Sometimes, if your department allows it and your question is narrow enough. Ask your supervisor early. A solo student should also consider a scoping or carefully designed structured review if the full method is not realistic.

How long does a systematic review take? Usually many months, and often more than the time available for an undergraduate project. The exact time depends on the number of records, the team size and the complexity of the topic.

What is PRISMA? PRISMA is a reporting guideline for systematic reviews, including a checklist and a flow diagram that shows how studies were identified, screened and included. Guidance is available on the PRISMA statement website.

Is a meta-analysis the same as a systematic review? No. A meta-analysis is a statistical method for combining results from several studies. A systematic review may include one, but many do not.

What is the difference between a systematic review and a scoping review? A systematic review answers a focused question, usually with quality appraisal. A scoping review maps the range and nature of evidence on a broader topic, and often does not assess quality in depth.

How many studies do I need in a systematic review? There is no fixed number. It depends on how much relevant research exists. Some reviews include a handful of studies, others hundreds. What matters is that your method is transparent and your question is answerable.

Do I need two reviewers? Independent screening by two reviewers is standard practice because it reduces bias. If you are working alone, say so and describe any checks you made.

Which databases should I use? Choose databases that match your field and that your library can access, and use more than one. Examples include PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, ERIC and African Journals Online, plus supplementary sources. Always record your searches.

Can I use AI tools to run my review? Policies differ by university. Some tools can help organise or screen records, but you remain responsible for accuracy, and tools can invent sources. Check your department’s rules, verify every reference and describe any tool use honestly.

Can someone help me plan or write my review? Yes. Professional guidance is legitimate when used within your university’s rules. Our team offers research proposal writing, dissertation proposal writing, thesis writing and complete dissertation writing support tailored to Nigerian university standards.

Need Help Choosing and Writing the Right Review?

Choosing the wrong review type can derail a project, while the right one makes your argument stronger and your defence easier. Writely.ng can help you decide between a literature review and a systematic or scoping review, structure your search and selection process and present your review clearly. Explore our research proposal writing, thesis writing and dissertation writing services.

Get a free quote today and build a review you can defend with confidence.


Catch Up On the Rest of Our posts:

  • hasnain-sajid-hakeem-nVBPy9S2USQ-unsplash
    How to Write a Company Profile: Template and Examples
  • lilartsy-333oj7zFsdg-unsplash
    Employee Handbook: What to Include for Nigerian Employers
  • eugene-chystiakov-wcMysLw5ROM-unsplash
    How to Write an MBA Assignment That Scores a Distinction
  • debby-hudson-DR31squbFoA-unsplash
    Does Turnitin Detect AI Writing? What Students Should Know
  • kelly-sikkema-xcvXS6wDCAY-unsplash
    How to Write a Case Study (Business, Nursing, Law)…
  • kelly-sikkema-HymOWIY2o3s-unsplash
    How to Write a Pitch Deck Script for Investors
  • beku-kanomi-c4vUTnU7Q3o-unsplash
    How to Write a Term Paper in 7 Steps
  • khalid-alshehri-VIyjkVlDhqk-unsplash
    How to Write a Company Profile: Template and Examples
  • lilartsy-333oj7zFsdg-unsplash
    How to Lower Your Plagiarism Percentage Ethically
  • debby-hudson-DR31squbFoA-unsplash
    Local SEO for Lagos Businesses: A Practical Guide
  • nedimshoots-6CQy1skIbRs-unsplash (1)
    SOP Writing: How to Create Standard Operating Procedures
  • Z1SKYfMwAClLWQGa-generated_image
    Sponsorship Proposal Template for Events in Nigeria

How to Design a Questionnaire for Your Final Year Project
Previous Article
How to Write a Research Ethics Statement
Next Article

Abuja Office

16, Ademola Adetokunbo Crescent,
Wuse 2, Abuja Nigeria

Lagos Office

4th Floor, Suite 3AB, No 34/36 Ikorodu Road, Jibowu, Lagos

Port Harcourt Office

129-132 Old Michelin Compound Trans Amadi ind.Layout, Port harcourt Rivers

Ibadan Office

TDL House, 4 Ososami Rd, New GRA, Ibadan 200252, Oyo, Nigeria

“Exceptional service! Writely's content writing services in Nigeria are professional, reliable, and results-driven. Highly recommended!.”

Joaan Hensen

Request a free
consultancy

Writely offers top-notch content writing services in Nigeria, UK, US, UAE, and 103 countries; delivering expertly crafted content tailored to your unique needs. Our team specializes in creating high-quality, engaging, and SEO-optimized content to help businesses stand out. Trust Writely for professional content and writing services in Nigeria that drive results and elevate your brand presence.
Get In Touch
writely ng logo

Writely delivers exceptional content writing services in Nigeria, UK, USA, UAE, Canada and 105 countries

we pride ourselves on providing exceptional content writing services in Nigeria, Our professional content and writing services in Nigeria ensure your message resonates and delivers measurable impact.

Twitter Linkedin Instagram

Explore

Home
About Us
Our Services
Portfolio
Contact

Clients

Membership Login
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
Table of Contents

Address

Email: [email protected]
Suite 3AB, 4th Floor,  No 34/36 Ikorodu Road, Jibowu, Lagos

Copyright 2025-31 by Writely Content Services All Right Reserved.