What is recommendation letter writing?
Writing a reference or recommendation letter from what the recommender personally witnessed, so that a reader can believe it. It is not the same craft as writing to be read: nothing in one of these documents is enjoyed, and every sentence exists to produce a belief. The work assembles a claim list with the moment attached to each entry, finds a real comparator if one exists, replaces adjectives with particulars, removes anything that repeats the curriculum vitae, and hands the recommender the finished list of what they are signing.
What does a recommender need to give you?
Moments rather than adjectives, and that is really the whole brief. Which projects, which cohort, which year, what this person did in a room, how they behaved when something went wrong, what they did when nobody was checking. Along with their own position and how well they know the candidate, and anything they have already decided they will not claim. The last of those saves the most trouble, because a recommender who has said no to something in advance is far easier to write with than one discovering the limit halfway through.
How long should a recommendation letter be?
Long enough to carry four or five real claims and short enough that a reader with two hundred letters reaches the end. In practice that is usually one page, and the discipline that keeps it there is that nothing goes in unless it is on the claim list. A letter that runs to two pages is almost always one where adjectives have been allowed in, since particulars are compact and adjectives are not. Where a form specifies a limit, that limit decides and the content is fitted to it.
What if the recommender is hesitant or lukewarm?
It is the common case rather than the exception, and it is solvable without inflating anything. Inflating an honest letter turns it into one nobody believes and puts the recommender somewhere they will not describe afterwards. What works is narrower claims stated firmly: fewer adjectives, more particulars, and the one thing this person did that the reader will remember. Where the honest answer is that the candidate is capable but not outstanding, that is agreed up front and produces a perfectly good letter, which is better than the hedged version everybody writes instead.
Can you write in the recommender's voice?
To an extent, and reading something they have already written is the most useful input available, because it shows how firmly they are willing to speak. But the voice is the easy half. The hard half is that they did not choose the sentences and they cannot approve them one at a time without being given something to approve, which is why the finished letter goes out with its claim list attached. What should not happen is anybody other than the recommender deciding how strongly they are willing to speak, and that is the conversation this service starts with.
Is it acceptable to include comparisons?
Where a real one exists, it is usually the strongest claim in the letter. Best of the six students I have supervised since 2019 carries the recommender’s own standard inside it, which tells the reader both what the candidate is and what good looks like to the person writing, and it is checkable in a way that no adjective is. What is not acceptable is manufacturing one. Best of six is only available to somebody who supervised six, and an invented comparison is a claim the recommender cannot answer for when the reader rings to check.
What if the recommender does not know the applicant well?
Then the letter should be narrow, and honest about being narrow, because a letter from a near-stranger has a completely different job from one from a supervisor. What it can still carry is the one or two things they actually witnessed, which is usually more than people expect. It cannot carry anything about character under pressure, which is exactly what a reader most wants and exactly what nobody can attest to having seen. So the structure is short, specific, and clear about the capacity in which the recommender knows the candidate.
Who writes the letter, the recommender or the candidate?
The recommender, in every sense that matters, and the arrangement on this page is that the claims are theirs while the sentences are written for them. Which is not the same as ghostwriting and is worth being clear about, because the candidate is not the client here: they have no standing over what is said about them and cannot approve a claim about themselves. In practice that means the recommender signs, the claim list is agreed with them, and the candidate is told what the letter says rather than editing it.
How specific should it be about weaknesses?
One, stated once, in proportion, with what came of it, and then no further hedging. A letter with no weakness in it reads as one nobody read properly, because everybody knows what a real one contains. A letter that turns a small weakness into a strength is the same error in different clothing and readers are now trained to spot it. The practical effect is that a single honest limit in a page of praise makes the rest of the page believable, which is the opposite of what hedging does.
Can you guarantee the outcome?
No, and it would not be worth doing if it could. The outcome belongs to a panel or a hiring manager who has the whole file in front of them, and a letter is one part of it. What this service can do is remove the reasons a letter gets set aside: a claim nobody can check, a paragraph that repeats what is already in the file, an honest recommendation turned into an obviously inflated one, or a document that arrives after the deadline. None of that is a guarantee and all of it is within reach.
How quickly can it be delivered?
Quickly, but the constraint is the recommender rather than the writing. If they are available for one conversation about what they witnessed, a letter is straightforward. If they are travelling, or awkward, or slow to answer, nothing in the writing will fix that and it is better to know on the first day than the last. Where a deadline is tight the useful move is to agree the claim list first and write from it, rather than sending a questionnaire that comes back with adjectives a week before the closing date.
Where is Writely available, and how do I start?
Writely is based in Nigeria and works remotely with applicants, academics, professionals and institutions across Nigeria and the rest of Africa. Use the
Chat with us button to send whatever the recommender remembers, how well they know the candidate, and anything they have already decided not to claim. That is enough to begin, and enough to say honestly whether this recommender can write this letter.