What is business proposal writing, and what is it not?
It is finding out who holds the pen, listing the reasons that person has for declining, and writing a document that answers each one where the reader will look for it. The work before drafting is most of the work. What it is not is brochure copy about your organisation, and the version most senders write is that. It is also not a promise of acceptance, which nobody who writes proposals honestly can make: the decision depends on who else is bidding, what the reader already believes, and whether your figures compare well with alternatives that are not in your document.
What should a business proposal contain?
Enough that the reader can decide without asking you anything, which usually means: what problem you are solving and how you know it exists, what you will actually deliver and by when, what it will take in money and what the reader gets back, what happens if it goes wrong, what you are not doing, and the single decision you are asking for. Two additions that earn their place more often than not: the reader's own alternatives, including doing nothing, stated fairly; and a named person accountable for the work, because decisions tend to get made about people rather than about documents.
How long should a business proposal be?
As long as the reader's questions and not as long as your material. A reader who is genuinely choosing between several options has time for twenty pages; a reader filling in a formality does not, and a long document there reads as an obstacle rather than as thoroughness. The test is whether every section closes a doubt the reader actually has, and whether deleting any one section would lose the argument. If it would not, it goes. Length becomes a problem when it is being used to stand in for evidence
How do I make a proposal stand out from other bids?
By being answerable rather than by being more enthusiastic. Most bids arrive making the same claims in the same order, so the proposal that is easiest to check wins more often than the proposal that is best written. Three things do most of the work: state the reader's real alternatives including doing nothing, since that is the comparison being made; show the working behind the figures, which shifts the argument from whether they trust you to whether they accept your assumptions; and write the exclusions down, because a sender who has thought about the boundary reads as safer than one who has promised everything. A specific fact about your own track record beats any adjective, provided the fact is one the reader can check.
Should the commercial terms be broken down, and how detailed?
Broken down enough that the reader can see what drives the total, and no further, because detail past the point of usefulness reads either as padding or as an invitation to negotiate the parts you were vague about. Show the main items, the basis of each, and the assumptions that would move the total. Be clear about what is excluded and what happens when the scope changes, since an unstated change mechanism is an argument the reader will win. If the reader has asked for a lump sum, respect that and put the breakdown in the appendix rather than arguing for it in the body.
What do most business proposals get wrong?
Arranging the document in the sender's order rather than the reader's, which is what the difference is: what the company is, then what the team can do, then what the client gets. The reader's order is nearer: is this a problem worth my attention, can these people do it, what happens if it goes wrong, what does it take me, who decides, and when. Third, ending with four decisions instead of one, which lets a reader defer all of them and find the delay reasonable.
How do you handle a proposal with a very tight deadline?
Shorten the document rather than the thinking. What can be cut quickly: the company's history, staff photographs, general claims about service quality, and anything answering a question the reader has not asked. What cannot be cut is the doubt table, because a fast document built without one fails on the objection nobody anticipated. If the deadline leaves no time for real analysis, say so in the brief and the proposal will be built on the strongest available evidence with the weak points marked rather than hidden. A proposal submitted a day late is usually worse than a shorter one submitted on time, because the reader has already moved on.
Do I need a capability statement as well?
Usually yes for anything competitive, because they are read at different moments by different people. The capability statement is scanned to decide whether you are worth a meeting; the proposal is read to decide whether to choose you. So the statement carries credentials, qualifications and track record, kept to two pages and written so it can be dropped into a tender pack unchanged. What should not happen is the proposal repeating it, which is where a great deal of padding comes from. If you already have one, send it in the brief: a better use of the hours is spent on the reader's doubts.
What happens if I am shortlisted but not chosen?
It is the most useful outcome available short of winning, so it is worth reading properly rather than as a loss. A shortlist means your figures and your credibility were accepted, and usually means the gap was in a specific place rather than everywhere. Ask for that, plainly and without complaint, because most buyers will say more than they expect and almost none will volunteer it. Then send something short: what you would do differently, one point where you think the work would have been stronger, and a date you would be ready to start. Senders who do this tend to come back, and senders who send nothing after a shortlist tend to be forgotten.
How do you handle a formal tender with mandatory documents?
Compliance first and prose second, because in a formal tender a missing document is a disqualification and a beautiful narrative does not recover it. So the pack is checked against the published list item by item before anything is written, and anything required in a particular form is produced in that form. Read the guidance and the guidance about the guidance, because several institutions publish a bidder pack and its own note on how submissions will be weighed, and the second one changes what you write. Only then does drafting begin, with the doubt table folded inside whatever document structure the tender requires rather than beside it.
Can you write the proposal or do I keep it?
We build it with you and your team keeps it, What we produce is the reader note, the doubt table, the figures appendix, and the proposal itself, and they are yours to edit from then on. What we will not do is promise acceptance, write a case on figures that cannot be defended, or invent evidence for a claim you are making. If the honest answer is that you cannot win this one, the doubt table will show it early rather than after you have spent a fortnight on it.
Where is Writely available, and how do I start?
Writely is based in Nigeria and works remotely with businesses, consultancies and teams across Nigeria and the rest of Africa. Use the
Chat with us button to send the essentials, because the reader note is the first thing we build and it cannot be written without knowing who signs. Say what the reader already believes about you, if anything, and what their real alternatives are, including doing nothing. Send the actual figures rather than a range, tell us what you would refuse to include in scope, and give the submission date and any decision date you already know. From that we can usually say within one exchange whether the proposal is worth writing and which way round it.